| |
Chat Transcript:
January 21st 2001: Jumpin' at the Diner
Sunday
January 21st (in LinguaMOO)
This
transcript produced by Deena Larsen
Straight
to log missing introduction
A Hypertext
Jukebox of great web works In Spring 2000, Riding the Meridian featured a "Progressive
Dinner Party" -- a celebration of women creating English-language literature
on the WWW (curated by Carolyn Guertin and Marjorie Coverley Luesebrink). The
Winter 2000 edition of Riding the Meridian features "Jumpin' at the Diner"
-- A spankin' new survey of web-work created by men, curated by Marjorie Coverley
Luesebrink with Jennifer Ley, and commentary by Jay Bolter and Stephanie Strickland.
We
will cover:
- What
common themes and issues do these works address?
- How
are authors using new and changing technologies?
- Why
are authors choosing the forms they choose--(what are we *saying*
that we can't say in linear print)?
-
How do graphics and text merge into meaning?
MD
Coverley (Marjorie Coverley Luesebrink, MFA) writes electronic
hypermedia fiction. Her interest in hypertext fiction and web
hypermedia dates to 1995, when she published "The Virtual
Mausoleum," one of the early web narratives. Her full-length
novel, Califia, is available on CD-ROM from Eastgate Systems.
Her web short stories and poetry have appeared in Iowa
Review Web, Beehive,
Alt-X, frAme,
Riding
the Meridian, cauldron
& net, Salt
Hill, New
River, Enterzone,
Aileron,
and in publication of the trAce
community. Her work has been featured at the Guggenheim Museum
in New York, at the Transcriptions Series at UC Santa Barbara,
at the Digital Arts Center at UCLA, and on-line at trAce (Nottingham
University, UK), at the TP21CL
(Technology Platforms for the 21st Century) at Brown University,
Blast 5 (Alt X), and Room Without Walls. She curated the collection
of women writing on the web with Carolyn Guertin, "The
Progressive Dinner Party" (Riding the Meridian, Spring
2000) and a survey of men in web hypermedia, "Jumpin' at
the Diner" in the Fall 2000 issue of Riding the Meridian.
Her non-fiction work has been published extensively both on line
and in print. She is a founding member of the Board of Directors
of the Electronic Literature Association. Marjorie Luesebrink
lives in Newport Beach, CA and teaches writing at Irvine Valley
College.
Stephanie
Strickland's
manuscript, "V," won the 2000 Alice Fay Di Castagnola Award from
the Poetry Society of America. Her most recent essay on hypermedia,
"Dali Clocks: Time Dimensions of Hypermedia" has just appeared
in the wEBaRts issue of ebr.
"Errand Upon Which We Came," a Web poem created with MD Coverley,
is forthcoming in cauldron
& net. "To
Be Here as Stone Is," also created with MD Coverley, was published
in Riding
the Meridian. Strickland's "Ballad
of Sand and Harry Soot" was chosen for an About.com Best of
the Net award, and True North, her full-length hypertext poem
from Eastgate Systems, won a Salt
Hill Hypertext Prize. Recent print articles about hypertext
and new media appear in American Letters & Commentary 12 and the
Jan/Feb issue of Poets and Writers. Her print volumes of poetry
include _True North_, _The Red Virgin: A Poem of Simone Weil_,
and _Give the Body Back._
Founder
of the internet literary magazine Riding
the Meridian, much of Jennifer Ley's newest work is
in the field of hypertext and hypermedia. Examples can be found
on the web at SUNY Buffalo's Electronic
Poetry Center, in the web journals Iowa
Review Web, cauldron
& Net, frAme4,
The
Animist, Snakeskin,
and Conspire,
and in the trAce anthology: My
Millennium. Ley's web works have been exhibited on the NJN/PBS
Series, State of the Arts, at Digital Arts and Culture '99, SIGGRAPH
2000 Art Gallery, the Ink.ubation Salon sponsored by trAce online
writing community, as well as at digital conferences planned this
year in South Africa and Eastern Europe.
The
following is a list of related links to accompany your reading.
- Jumpin'
at the Diner
- The
Progressive Dinner Party
- trAce
- ELO
- The
Iowa Review Website
- Beehive
- Alt-X
- frAme
- Riding
the Meridian
- Salt
Hill
- New
River
- Enterzone
- Aileron
- Stephanie
Strickland's "To
Be Here as Stone Is" and "Ballad
of Sand and Harry Soot"
- SUNY
Buffalo's Electronic
Poetry Center
- The
Animist
- Snakeskin
- Conspire
- trAce's
My
Millenium
- Impermanence
Agent (chat with Noah Wardrip Fruin, a.c. chapman, Brion
Moss, and Duane Whitehurst on November
05, 2000)
- Talan
Memmott's
Lexia to Perplexia (previous chats with Talan Memmott and
Mez on January
26, 2000; as a featured writer in Marjorie Luesebrink's
the Dinner
Party on February
23, 2000)
- Jim
Rosenberg's home page and The
Barrier Frames
- Bobby
Rabyd's Sunshine
'69
- The
Unknown (Scott Rettberg, William Gillespie, Dirk Stratton
), it's
definition of hypertext and a feminist
critique
- Peter
Howard's The
Rainbow Factory
- Darcey
Stienke's adaweb
- Tom
Bell's Metaphor
- mEIKAL
aND and Marion Damon's erosion
- ELO
directory
- Carolyn
Guertin's Assemblage
- Lingua
MOO
- Electronic
Writers Workshops schedules
- Joel
Weishaus' Inside
the Skull House (will be workshopped at OWEL).
- Deena
Larsen's Samplers
used Storyspace
from Eastgate
- The
trAce/ELO chat next February
4, 2001 will talk with Talan Memmott, winner of the New
Media Prize, then FraMe authors (Digital Labour, For Love or
Money?) on February
18, 2001, and then the winner of the ELO prize in May 20,
2001."
- TP21CL
Technology Platforms for 21st Century Literature Conference
- Digital
Arts and Culture
- Deena
Larsen's Kanjis
(listed on home page)
- Crossartist
- Jamba
- E
Poetry 2001 Festival at SUNY Buffalo
- ELO
Awards
--
Start log: Sunday, January 21, 2001 2:34:49 p.m. CST
Margie
quietly enters.
Deena
says, "Hi Margie"
Margie
says, "Hi Deena"
Deena
shares a URL...<http://www.deenalarsen.net/jd>.
Deena
says, "The URL on the side shows what we are discussing and
provides links to Jumpin'
at the Diner "
Margie
says, "Deena! oh, that is cool. How do you whisper?"
Deena
says, "Type "Page name message". Actually that is
page, but it works better. "
Margie
says, "Ok, do you do it from normal, or say--and do you
use the quote marks? I have not been able to get this to work."
Deena
says, "Margie, close, but take out the " mark first. Just type
page."
Bobbyrabyd
arrives.
Margie
says, "Hi Bobby!"
Margie
says, "Deena! can you help?"
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Hi Margie . . . great to "See" you."
Margie
says, "Hey Bobby, how is 2001 treating you?"
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Well, thanks . . . there's a foot of snow on the ground
here in RI. How's your power holding out?"
Margie
says, "No outage yet today, but if I disappear, you will
know what has happened!"
Deena
says, "There is a lot of snow here, as well..."
Deena
says, "Have you had rolling blackouts there?"
Bobbyrabyd
says, "As always, no? Deena?"
Deena
says, "Well, no, usually Denver doesn't have *much* snow."
Margie
says, "We have not had rolling blackouts at my house, but
there have been colleges in the area that have had to shut down.
Not ours, tho--we just have turned off the heat--egad."
Deena
says, "My ISP just quit, so I am at Kinkos again..."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "I'm curious . . . how does one 'view' Jumpin'
at the Diner ?"
Margie
says, "Do you mean that you can't get to it?"
Deena
says, "Just click on the
Diner button there, Bobby."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Ah! I see it! Thanks!"
Margie
says, "D, I am going to get a coke--right back."
Deena
serves cokes to all and sundry.
Deena
says, "Bobby, how long have you been at Brown? Do you like the
programs there?"
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Great music! on the juke!""
Margie
says, "Thanks!"
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Deena . . . it's funny: two answers to that question.
One of them is 6 months, the other is 13 years . . . (more)"."
Deena
says, "OK, how does that work with 6 months and 13 years?"
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Deena: I started studying here in '87, but only last
summer got hired full-time."
Deena
says, "Ahh. Which program did you study under?"
Bobbyrabyd
says, "English/Literature and Creative Writing."
Deena
says, "I would love to hear more about the Brown program sometime..."
Scott,
a.c.chapman, Tom, JimR, and Stephanie/Janet arrive.
Deena
serves coke, hot chocolate, and more caffeine to get us psyched
to enter the
Diner
Deena
takes orders in the
Diner on roller skates.
Deena
says, "Can people see the URL on the right side of the screen?
<http://www.deenalarsen.net/JD>."
Scott
says, "Nice, Deena. handy."
Bumpy
Guest arrives.
Deena
rushes around greeting newcomers and taking orders on her diner
roller skates.
Deena
says, "On this site, you can see a list of authors featured
in Jumpin'
at the Diner ."
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Hi everyone--Janet's typing for Stephanie."
Deena
says, "Jumpin'
at the Diner is the male counterpart for the Progressive
Dinner Party
in Spring 2000's Riding the Meridian (which we discussed February
23, 2000 )."
Deena
says, "Marjorie Luesebrink curated both of these and Stephanie
Strickland and Jay Bolter commented."
Margie
says, "There are forty men featured in Jumpin'
at the Diner--but we found, but the end of the time we were
working, we could have had many more."
MazThing
pops in.
Deena
says, "People are still joining us.. I'm trying to sort out
who is here"
Weishaus
arrives.
Deena
says, "Could people introduce themselves? We have some stellar
guests here..."
Margie
says, "I was particularly interested in all the new ways that
these creative men were using new techniques in electronic literature--"
Margie
says, "Hi Joel. "
Tom
says, "I've been having problems with my digestion since the
Diner appeared. Anybody else?"
Deena
surreptitiously hands out lots of tums.
Margie
says, "Ha! it's the variety."
Marvella
arrives from Lost Property Office.
jenniferley
arrives.
Scott
says, "Both of these projects have done a great deal to
demonstrate the breadth and variety of work going on in the
field right now. Hats off on Progressive
Dinner Party
and Jumpin'
at the Diner."
Deena
throws many hats in the air
lugh
arrives.
Margie
says, "I do think introductions would be good. Several of the
artists featured in the
Diner are here today."
Saada
arrives.
Margie
says, "Deena is on at Kinko's today, so she probably got a nod."
jenniferley
says, "Mmm, I have to try to remember how to do all this
!! ... wonderful to see so many people here."
Saada
says, "Hello everyone." Margie
says, "Hello Saada. Scott, could you maybe start, followed
by Bobby, Tom, Joel, and others I have missed?"
a.c.chapman
says, "Goodness, there are so many of us."
Cybele
(mEIKAL) arrives.
lugh
says, "Deena's at Kinko's? Why? She has a box at home and at
work."
Margie
says, "Also, Reiner Strasser sent his regrets, his phone
has been out all week."
jenniferley
says, "Maybe Deena likes Kinkos ;)"
Deena
says, "I am at Kinkos because my computer quit at the last second
and CHISP
dumped me out..."
Margie
says, "Given the vagaries of technology, it is a wonder
that so much good work gets done."
MazThing
smiles and waves to Cybele, thinking 'long time no see/read.'
Marvella
says, "Hmmm, am I invisible?"
MazThing
says, "Nope."
Deena
says, "HI Marvella, I can see you. Please introduce yourself
:)"
Scott
says, "I'm Scott Rettberg, one of the coauthors of the
Unknown. I think William is planning on making it though who
knows and I believe Dirk was planning on showing up late after
a round of disc golf."
Marvella
says, "Thanks, I thought I wasn't a mermaid anymore."
Deena
hands rounds everyone's orders from the Diner, which just happen
to be everyone's favorite foods and drinks.
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Mmm! Mallomars!""
a.c.chapman
says, "Can I get some catsup with these?"
Deena
hands out never ending bottles of catsup and ketchup and mustard.
Weishaus
says, "Can I use food stamps?"
Deena
smiles and says all orders are on the house tonight
a.c.chapman
says, "Thanks"
Cybele
says, "Hi all mIEKAL here.."
Deena
says, "I'm Deena, the chat host, trying to keep things in order.
Thanks so much to all the authors featured in the
Diner, Marjorie, Stephanie, Jay, Jennifer for doing all
the hard work and showing up at the chat."
Margie
says, "Hey mIEKAL, but who would know. MIEKAL and is also
featured in the
Diner."
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Anyone here from Steph's 526 class?"
Scott
offers students in Steph's class extra credit for attending
trAce/ELO
chats
Bobbyrabyd
takes extra credit and runs, exclaiming like D. Duck, "Mine!
mine! all mine!"
Cybele
says, "I think I forgot how to MOO... its gonna take me a bit
"
Deena
shares a URL...<http://www.deenalarsen.net/JD>.
jenniferley
says, "Nice work Deena !!"
Margie
says, "So, Bobby Rabyd, Joel Weishaus, Tom Bell (I am guessing),
MIEKAL, and who else from the
Diner juke box here?"
Deena
says, "You can click to see the commentaries, and scroll down
to see the authors"
gaberbocchus
arrives from trAce
Deena
says, "Scott, a.c. Chapman from Impermanence
Agent. Noah is protesting at the capitol today... :)"
Editor's note: see the chat
with the Impermanence Agent authors (Noah Wardrip Fruin, a.c.
chapman, Brion Moss, and Duane Whitehurst) on November
05 , 2000. The current chat was held on the same day as
Bush's inauguration.
a.c.chapman
says, "Y'all should call me Adam. Most recently, I participated
in one of these chats for a project called The
Impermanence Agent which was done with Noah Wardrip-Fruin
(who sends his hellos) and Brion Moss and Duane Whitehurst."
jenniferley
says, "Good for Noah. " Deena cheers Noah on and is there
in spirit.
You
see a shimmering bright light as Jan suddenly materializes out
of thin air.
Margie
says, "Good to have you, a.c."
Deena
says, "Hi Jan, we are settling in to talk with authors and commentators
and curators on the chat."
Jan
finds a seat in Eliterature.
Deena
says, "Stephanie, you really address this in your commentary,
but what common threads do you see in these works?"
Stephanie/Janet
says, "The differences are at least as important as what's in
common."
lugh
says, "I heard that."
a.c.chapman
says, "Stephanie, please elaborate."
Deena
says, "What do you see as the differences?"
Deena
gestures to all to jump in.
Cybele
says, "Content."
Tom
says, "I'm focused on food these days as my infopoem fGId has
turned into a real-life social movement related to IBS. I'll
mention it once and then won't bore you all.""
Deena
says, "Tom, I really am interested to see how the poem turns
into a real life movement."
Stephanie/Janet
says, "I see forms emerging very distinct from print precursors.
Certainly Talan's piece, for instance."
Editor's note: This is Lexia
to Perplexia winner of the trAce/ Alt-X
New Media contest. We'll talk with Talan on February
4, 2001.
Deena
says, "Meikal, what about the content?"
Margie
says, "I think that we could find a huge range to talk about,
but I wonder if folks noticed how many different ways that links
were used, for example."
Cybele
says, "That's what I always notice most about web works,
& this collection is no different"
Deena
says, "Are there more differences and variations in works now
than say a year or two ago?"
Margie
says, "Some navigation was by standard word-to-word, some by
drag-drop, some by sliding panels, some by mouseover. and then
there were the pushed links, done with flash...."
Tom
says, "It's complicated but there now is an Internet email
group bombing the FDA and public citizen with e-mails - I'll
say more bc later if you want"
jenniferley
says, "I think there are Deena ... but that's because the tech
gives us more options"
Deena
says, "I really noticed the different ways people used technology,
Suture and Rainbow factory have such very different feels from
Sailing, for example"
Stephanie/Janet
says, "(and from each other)"
April_Guest
quietly enters.
Deena
says, "Hi April_Guest, we are talking about the many different
ways authors use links and technologies. Please introduce yourself
:)"
Deena
says, "How are authors using these technologies? How are we
engaging in these different forms?"
Margie
says, "Yes, we are getting such a range of look-feel--the
difference, for example between Joel's work and Peter Howard's
Rainbow, and then a.c. And Noah's Impermanence
Agent."
Deena
says, "Authors, could you talk a bit about WHY you chose to
use the technology you chose? Why you chose to present links
in the way you chose? And please introduce your works. You can
share the URLs by typing @URL http://www.whatever..."
Cybele
says, "That's an easy answer for me...When I did that particular
piece almost 4 years ago, its all I knew about."
JimR
says, "Ahem. Some of us don't use links."
Margie
says, "Hey Jim--welcome. But, in the sense that the computational
folks use it, the morphing text is a link, as well, no?"
jenniferley
says, "Or a mouse over ??"
Deena
grins at JimR--right. The word symphonies that you are working
with really do transcend the link, Jim."
Editor's note: see Jim
Rosenberg's home page for a list of these works.
JimR says, "No Margie, I don't think so."
Margie
says, "What we know is that this variety is a fairly new
phenomenon--two years ago, we would have had a great selection,
but no where near the tech variety."
Stephanie/Janet
says, "mIEKAL, could you talk more about how your piece
connects up with real life? (Hi, Maura!)"
Maura
arrives and says, "I made it.""
Deena
says, "Hi Maura, glad you made it. We are talking to authors
featured in the
Diner about why they chose forms, links, and technologies"
Cybele
says, "Hmmmm...Not sure how to answer that question....For
me all work that exists on the computer is its own self-sustaining
reality. Not a simulation"
Weishaus
says, "Mine evolved from work on paper, developing a form of
hyperlinks before the WWW arrived.""
Deena
says, "Joel, how did the paper links transform into electronic
links?"
Tom
says, "S/j. are you asking mIEKAL or me? "
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Both of you, Tom -- "
Weishaus
[to Cybele]: "It's Joel speaking. Yes, that's true."
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Janet asks, don't some folks consider morphing text "Light
links"?"
a.c.chapman
says, "Light links?"
jenniferley
says, "Byte links ??"
Marvella
says, "No calories?"
a.c.chapman
laughs
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Let's put it this way--can someone explain how a mouseover
is or isn't a link?"
lugh
says, "No calories, but a few ergs..."
Deena
passes out calorie free and delicious links, light links, and
smart morphing links
Tom
says, "My latest begins with a day on an internet self-help
group that has been turned to a group to petition the FDA -
it's happening right now. It's both a poem and a piece in process.
The interactions and connections people are making are actually
happening now on the Internet"
Marvella
says, "One thing leads to another"
Pilarius
arrives.
Margie
says, "Hi Pilarius--can you tell us about yourself?"
Deena
says, "Hi Pilarius, we are talking about the different ways
authors featured in the
Diner use links and technology."
lugh
says, "It's a passive link - you don't go anywhere from which
to come back. It's like a window into which you look while walking
down a street; links are the intersections and doorways."
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Nice metaphor, lugh!" lugh says, "Thanks."
Cybele
says, "Who's lugh?"
Deena
urges everyone to introduce themselves again.
lugh
says, "Russ Bixby, geek at large and unix zealot. Hi."
Margie
says, "Well, then we need some more names for links, something
we might have suspected."
a.c.chapman
says, "That's interesting. Do you still consider it a work
of literature or do you think of it more as a temporal performance?
"
Marvella
says, "Temporal performance is a nice phrase." a.c.chapman
says, "Thanks"
Deena
says, "Have we ever really defined what a link is? Do we need
to or should we be wary of such definitions"
lugh
says, "I do believe that definitions are important; with common
definitions, forums such as this will run more smoothly, no?"
Deena
says, "I don't know if definitions help or hinder...I'm beginning
to wonder."
JimR
says, "The issue of the difference between the kind of structures
I use and links is complicated. I use structures where a group
of peers are aggregated *together*. The concept of "Link"
doesn't really do this."
Marvella
says, "Would you use any architectural references, Jim?"
jenniferley
nods at JimR's distinction.
a.c.chapman
says, "Could you define piece in progress or what that
means to you?"
Margie
says, "Yes, Jim, but that is a function of the narrow categorical
definition of link so far--but I think we will all benefit from
your forthcoming paper about this!!!"
JimR
says, "Thanks for the plug, Margie!"
JimR
says, "Marvella, I'm not sure what you mean by architectural."
Marvella
says, "Spatial, for one thing.You used the word structural.""
Deena
says, "There are so many different kind of connections --temporal,
physical, etc..."
lugh
says, "They *can* hinder, by forming a thought-box from which
not all may escape, but are also useful when relating to one
another. You can't tell someone the way to the airport w/o words
such as "Right" and "East."
Cybele
says, "Jim, I have to say that I learned more about hypertext
in your 45 minute class last year than just about anywhere else."
Marvella
says, "Which I think of as architectural and here's another
architect."
mez
and clarissa arrive.
Deena
says, "Hi Clarissa and mez, we are talking about different uses
of structure and links in different works featured at the
Diner."
Marvella
says, "You're early like 6 something a.m.?" mez says, "Me
marvella? no its 8.30 here now *a.m.*" Marvella says, "Ah,
late."
Tom
says, "2 people meet on the Internet and decide they are going
to write congress, for example. They look up the address and
do it and encourage others to do it also."
Marvella
says, "Seems like Tom is referencing a more social political
realm and Jim something more interior and musical but correct
me."
Deena
says, "We are using links and connections to refer to so many
things here Marvella!"
Deena
passes around hot coffee and homemade cinnamon rolls and sausage
links from the
Diner.
lugh
says, "Coffee. Hmmm... good idea. Be right back."
Cybele
says, "Hi mez, mEIKAL here." mez says, "Wow, hey mIEKAL,
long time no teXt:)" Cybele says, "I have my first real
job in my life. Hard to get back to what's important." mez says,
"N.deed, mIEKAL:)"
Deena
says, "Margie, how did you chose the pieces to feature in the
Diner?""
Margie
says, "We started with a very long list of things to look at
that I had been bookmarking for over a year--egad! and the first
step was to visit them. Then, Jen, Steph, and I set up a viewing
round, each of us would visit and comment. then we looked at
the works together. The decision about individual works was
not as hard as what to include. Net/art/literature fuses into
other disciplines, as well."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "In 1996, when I was constructing Sunshine
'69, I asked myself: if narrative, like cyberspace, is a
three-dimensional network, then what would seem to be its axes,
its essential X, Y, and Z? I chose these three: time, space,
point of view. The driver navigates the time trajectory by a
schematic of the last six months of the 60s resembles one of
those ecclesiastical calendars. In this case, the passenger
may pick and choose from chapters attached to each of the '69-specific
chapters. Every day of the week there's a different story from
the death of the 60s. "
Margie
says, "I consider Bobby's Sunshine to be a kind of classic (you
can see the driver's side there)."
Deena
says, "Bobby, Jim, a.c.. I think in a way you are all dealing
with structure AS integral to the piece, yet the structures
come out in many different ways. Impermanence agent is very
temporal, Jim's work more spatial."
a.c.chapman
says, "Say, I find that the pieces I work on also change
as my knowledge of programming increases. Often I start by going
high-fallutin' then scaling back and asking what's essential
to a given piece. It's a different sort of "Structure"
question that needs to be considered when writing. -- At the
same time I try and steer clear from that whole "It's a
poem because it looks like a swan" thing. Structure needs to
be as integral to a piece as any other part. Sometimes that
means inventing new ones and which also means new kinds of "Links".--so
a definition can be squirrelly."
Tom
says, "There are several conversations at once, but that's
not bad?"
Editor's note: I move text so that
the conversations appear somewhat more rational. If you have
never watched the real logs unfold faster than your screen can
hold the letters, come join us and party realtime!
Deena
juggles lots of conversations at once and is dizzy at the end,
but has a real great time.
Cybele
says, "@more rest"
clarissa
says, "Here it is already one hour later, so I prefer wine."
Deena
passes out coffee that turns into wine on request.
lugh
says, "What about automatic links; a mouseover being a
bushwhacking href. I've done it and found it useful; how do
you feel...?"
Deena
says, "Lugh, what do you mean by bushwhacking?"
Scott
gags on a glass of coffee that tastes like Chianti.
Deena
thinks that wine/coffee may be a lot like this conversation--matching
too many very different, very beautiful works...
Weishaus
says, "Can we discuss 'new kinds of links.' I think this is
an important avenue to see down.""
lugh
says, "It's a surprise; the user is *not* expecting it."
Margie
says, "Scott, I thought you had left!"
Tom
says, "I want to throw out another piece: I find myself moving
away from technology more and more and wonder if I'm alone"
Cybele
says, "What's a new kind of link Joel?"
lugh
says, "A clickless hard link, in other words. Changes the page
and all."
Deena
says, "Tom, what do you mean by moving away from the technology?"
a.c.chapman
says, "Do we mean links, or actions initiated by user or
work?"
Scott
says, "Got froze up when checking out one of the works,
am back."
lugh
says, "UNIX doesn't "Froze up." Hrmph!"
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Tom: 'throw up' a URL! "
Tom
says, "Back to paper and pencil - away from tools and links."
jenniferley
says, "I don't think you're alone in that Tom."
lugh
says, "I use paper and pencil; or a static page w/ASCII art
or such, but not to the exclusion of other mechanisms by which
to impart my vision to another."
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Joel, do you feel that way, too?"
Deena
says, "The basic meaning of link is to connect--which I
think includes Jim's juxtapositions (ducks wildly here), and
the spatial, and more."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Margie: can you speak to what (if anything) you found
peculiarly 'male' about any of these pieces?"
Cybele
says, "Yikes."
Weishaus
says, "Someone just mentioned this, and I was wondering if this
leads anywhere interesting, as I'm always looking for different
ways to leap to reference materials.""
JimR
says, "The word link is getting us in trouble. The real issue
is *DOING*. What happens structurally is different from what's
there to *do*."
Deena
says, "All--how do you see structure interacting with the meaning
of a piece?"
mez
says, "Tom and Jen, my m.pat.ous is moving 2, stretching
b-yond the techne, though as yet I'm not sure 2 where x.actly...."
Margie
says, "Oh, yes, Bobby, I think I can! (crawls under table)."
Deena
says, "Jim, can you tell us more about clarifying between structure
and doing?"
Deena
passes around more m.pat.ous ness to all
mez
says, ":)"
Scott
says, "Unknown
were thinking similar to Bobby -- we didn't worry about time
so much, but were thinking navigation in terms of space and
cognition/linguistic connection."
jenniferley
says, "Correct me if I'm wrong Joel, but isn't the structure
of your works also a trope for how the brain functions (that's
simplistic but you get my gist??)"
Bobbyrabyd
waxes aggressive, "Well!?" ;-)
Weishaus
says, "I certainly use paper to make notations, carry around
a pad. I'm lost without a pen in my pocket."
Scott
shares a URL...<http://www.unknownhypertext.com/hypertext.htm>.
Deena
says, "Scott, Dirk, how did you use the topographic map as structure
in the Unknown?"
lugh
says, "To an extent. A sculpture is qualitatively different
to a photograph, as illustrated in CE3K."
Deena
says, "How do people use structures as trope? I am thinking
of the
Rainbow Factory, which uses a great over/under structure
to show the differences in presentations..."
JimR
says, "Take a typical button. What's there to do is click on
it. But that doesn't tell you whether what happens does or does
not have a bigger structural context. (This is pretty hard to
explain in chat ...)"
Deena
says, "Jim, yes, and the button doesn't show what the relationship
is to the structure."
JimR
says, "Right"
Tom
says, "How do I share a URL?"
Deena
says, "To share URLS, type @URL http://www.whatever"
Tom
says, "Maybe my mouse is broken?"
Margie
says, "Scrolling out the little one--Bobby, I think that one
of the things that characterizes this collection is a high degree
of risk and experimentation. We saw many clever things in this
collection--some working, and some taking real time and effort
to master. I think men are more confident that folks will take
the time to work through the technical, etc. "
Weishaus
says, "Jen, yes, that's true, but I think of it more as a quest
of the brain.""
a.c.chapman
says, "Margie, do you find that as a constant or something changing?"
Deena
says, "Margie, Stephanie, how did you see the experimentation
and branching out--was this experimenting with technology, structure,
content??"
Cybele
says, "Jim, by doing you mean what the reader does or the author?"
Margie
says, "The next thing I noticed among the men was a kind of
shorthand for experience--that is, they were more certain that
the default assumption would fall their way--"
a.c.chapman
says, "The default assumption?"
JimR
says, "mIEKAL, I was thinking of the reader, but of course the
issue extends to both."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Kind of like the classism implicit in S. A. T. questions,
Margie?"
Cybele
says, "I don't understand Margie? default assumption?"
Deena
says, "I would like to hear more about the default assumptions...
such as?"
Margie
says, "a.c.--I am not sure if this is a change--I would
think it characterized work by men from the get-go--witness
M. Joyce's guard links--"
MazThing
has disconnected.
Scott
says, "Well, I guess we were thinking that the what we
were thinking was with the map was that the work as a whole
is a storyworld -- you can navigate it in a spatial way, like
you would zoom in on a satellite map, or in the way that you
would navigate your way through the transit system of a major
city, switching train lines."
Cybele
says, "So what things an a reader do other than click,
enter text, & use the mouse?"
Weishaus
says, "I second that: 'The default assumption.' What does this
mean?""
Margie
says, "a.c. that is, if something isn't spelled out, what
is the assumption the reader would be expected to make to have
the piece work or make sense--women seem to feel that they need
to background more carefully, that they are not as likely to
be understood."
Deena
says, "Yes, I noticed that in Alan Sondheim and Barry Smilie's
Sailing, actually. where the assumption was that you would just
go to the bay instead of the city..."
Margie
says, "Yes, Deena, I think that Sailing is a perfect example
of the risk-taking and the assumption grounding...."
Deena
says, "Actually, Bobby Rabyd's Sunshine
'69 is
the same way--we assume we are in the driver's seat."
jenniferley
says, "Which might lead one to say that work by men is
often more linear"
Stephanie/Janet
says, "I don't think that's true... (men more linear)"
lugh
says, "Hmmm. I'd always thought I was digital rather than linear..."
jenniferley
says, "I don't think it is necessarily true anymore."
JimR
says, "There may be a limited vocabulary of what the reader
does "in the small", but when you get to larger-level units
it gets much more complicated."
Margie
says, "I am not sure that is more linear, although that may
be, but it is more spare in the sense of covering alternative
takes."
Guy
quietly enters.
Deena
says, "Hi Guy, we are talking about the assumptions in the pieces
featured in the
Diner--what are assumptions from a male point of view?"
Cybele
says, "I must not be male..."
jenniferley
says, "But I think there was a time when it seemed true
of hypermedia work by men."
a.c.chapman
says, "Has anyone seen the piece Darcey Stienke did for
adaweb?"
Deena
says, "a.c., do you have that URL?"
mez
fumbles with a gap, a meaning curve, a taste of text....
jenniferley
says, "Well you're different mIEKAL ;)"
Weishaus
says, "Margie, that doesn't sit right. Anyway, the term 'women,'
or 'men,' I don't think we can talk that broadly any more, happily."
lugh
says, "Tell it to Piers Anthony."
mez
echos Joel, mumbling thru the ether][ealality]
Margie
says, "Joel, of course you are right that it is hard to generalize
like that--but I was responding to the things I had noticed."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Can we still talk, 'male' and 'female' happily?"
Marvella
says, "Hmmm, working with Reiner, I didn't have much of a male/female
distinction."
Tom
shares a URL for his poem Metaphor
<http://members.tripod.com/~trbell/metaphor/metapho.htm>
Cybele
says, "Folks, remember some of us are on a slow connection...
too many URLS quickly is really tying up my browser..."
lugh
says, "That's funny- I've got two T1s here and am using a text-only
system - no browser..."
Tom
says, "Go to near the bottom to iFGd."
Cybele
says, "What are we looking at?"
mez
torques masculine, feminine, triats n.stead of absolutes, jigsaws
instead of gen][re][ders
a.c.chapman
says, "Le.cle"
mez
cs a limp button @ the botTom of the p][ure][age, playful n.scribed
on its shining chrome cover, dust on its surface and grooved
smooth
Tom
says, "The drug in question was only for women but it helped
men also."
Weishaus
says, "Of course this defeats the purpose of separating men
from woman by their work. Why was it approached this way?""
jenniferley
says, "Speaking as the publisher of both Jumpin'
at the Diner and the Progressive
Dinner Party
... I think there was a time, early last year, when it seemed
women were more playful in their use of tech ... but I think
that has changed , and of course, like any generalization, all/part
of this is false."
Deena
says, "I am not sure there is a clear distinction between men
and women...this may be more of a distinction between the works
a year ago, and those now? Yet, Margie, how many of the works
in the
Diner are new this year?"
Marvella
says, "Maybe it's a search for distinctions and inclusiveness."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Margie: I was assuming that, because women were looked
at first with Dinner
Party
(not unusual to have a women's-only forum), it was time to do
guys. . ."
Deena
says, "Jen, Margie, Steph, if you do a compendium next year,
would it be separated along gender lines?"
lugh
says, "Deena, you've seen my work. Is it "Male," "Female"
or neither?"
Margie
says, "The reason we did an issue on men was because we had
already done the women's issue for Women's history month--and
so we wanted to honor men, and by that time the gender thing
was set. I hope folks weren't offended, we should be able to
note gender without it being a dirty word."
Weishaus
says, "I didn't mean that men aren't different from women! Only
that there are shades between, which I don't think apply well
on the net."
Deena
says, "I have never been good at distinguishing gender from
a person's work..."
jenniferley
says, "I think the time to make gender distinctions is over,
for the present"
lugh
says, "Presactly!"
Weishaus
says, "Amen!""
Marvella
says, "Um, I like sexy work."
mez
resets the Gender Dis.tinct.ion Button.
Marvella
says, "And that often means differences Viva."
Deena
says, "I think it was a neat idea for the women's issue... I
think there is a lot of under rumblings here about women in
technology..."
Scott
says, "I also think that there was a point in doing a collection
that was just women first, since tech is generally such a testosterone
laden field. I think the breadth and depth of the
Progressive Dinner Party
collection did a great deal to demonstrate how much of the most
imp. Work in e-lit is being done in e-lit."
Cybele
shares a URL for mEIKAL aND and Marion Damon's erosion...
Margie
says, "Joel--the place that fine distinctions really don't apply
is the MOO, too fast, too confusing."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Weishaus reminds me of Bornstein's collaboration in _Nearly
Roadkill_ (print), which really works the cyber-distinctionlessness
of genre."
lugh
says, "Of course we're different, but the differences vary from
person to person and there's a lot of overlap."
mez
overlaps N links, hi-jinx :)
Deena
says, "We have a lot of collaborations in the
Diner--as shown by the URL now with mIEKAL and Maria. Could
the collaborators talk about how collaborating in a hypertext
shapes the work?"
lugh
says, "Testosterone laden? You don't know many geeks..."
lugh
says, ":)"
jenniferley
says, "Well, Meridian
did a women's issue 'first' as that honored a previous relationship
the magazine had to do a women's issue each year with Conspire."
Cybele
says, "Two levels of links here, the physical links, then
the windows piled up on each other was you read"
jenniferley
says, "Conspire being CK Tower's primarily text oriented online
magazine"
Deena
says, "Jennifer, do you have that URL?"
jenniferley
says, "http://www.conspire.org"
mez
streams a cord of text, netwurkers fumbling thru files of static
blooms, all wet N growing, po.10.ials fertile....
Margie
says, "See, I didn't think that this needed to insist that
there were polar opposites--some women's work is very risky,
and some men's very padded, or something."
jenniferley
says, "CK is doing another women's issue this year ... I am
not"
Deena
says, "Wait, is there any hypertext/new media work that is NOT
risky?"
lugh
says, "Tech writing. ;)"
Deena
hands out cordials of text...
Cybele
says, "Sure, there's a lot of derivative stuff out there..."
Deena
passes out risks to all and sundry...
Margie
says, "Oh Deena, I didn't mean risky in all the senses of doing
this kind of tech, I meant in the backgrounding, in what the
author expected the reader to do, without other information."
mez
risk-takes, re-moults, re:vis][ion][s
Tom
says, "I have felt at times that my drawing is my female side
but it's not that simple."
Weishaus
says, "Men are having an identity crisis now, which I think
is good, although there's a danger."
Cybele
says, "Joel, you gotta explain that one..."
Deena
says, "Joel, is the identity crisis in the literature?"
jenniferley
says, "I understand what you're saying Margie."
Tom
says, "The identity is in the process."
lugh
says, "Ahhh. A generalization. It's a wave phenomenon,
a pendulum. I don't fancy myself all that different from my
Khazak ancestors."
Deena
says, "Ahh, yes, I think this goes back to expectations and
default assumptions."
Molde
Guest arrives.
Deena
says, "Hi Molde, we are talking about assumptions and risk taking
in hypertext writing."
Stephanie/Janet
says, "I'm curious whether the male authors here found any reflection
of their gender in this collection?"
mez
wishes 4 a genderless ID, identic.caul twinned balances and
life-n r gees....
Margie
says, "It seems to me that identity is an ongoing question.
At first it seemed like it could be resolved once and for all-but
now we see that life is a journey"
Stephanie/Janet
says, "(yes, strickland)"
a.c.chapman
says, "I know that the risk/innovation level of the work I do
is somewhat dependent on who I'm able to collaborate with and
their knowledge base."
Weishaus
says, "Deena. No, I mean in general, as women slowly take back,
or balance, the power in societies. "
mez
after-lifes, re[][ar][sloves....
Deena
says, "Does that identity search show up in the writing and
in the assumptions being made?"
a.c.chapman
says, "It's interesting that we're discussing structure
perhaps more than content (if we can distinguish)."
Cybele
says, "I think this is one of the reasons that I'm always attracted
to gender ambiguous works..."
mez
cs a silver ball][ancing act, complex n complete.ing][
Margie
says, "I thought that the fact that we could just present 39
women and 40 men seemed to suggest that we hoped to say, here
they are, no hierarchies intended!"
Deena
passes around identity crises life jackets and yummy all flavor
life savers.
lugh
says, "And who we are trying to reach, whether we are after
a particular audience, wish to create a new audience or just
don't give a rats ear and are simply creating to create."
Cybele
says, "I think my audience is 200 years from now..."
Deena
says, "Good question, lugh. Did you see a great difference in
the audiences people were reaching?"
In
the distance you hear someone's alarm clock going off. Smiley_Guest
wavers and vanishes into insubstantial mist.
Marvella
says, "Will you add to these anthologies?"
Tom
says, "If I write I'm one person; if I draw, the action
is another identity's."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Stephanie: it's kind of exhilarating to be grouped with
men . . . reminds me of male encounter meetings in college in
the 80s: no nee4d to be ashamed of gender, can come in touch
with emotion and how we can help liberation of both genders
(i.e.: resist violence)--and we all write!"
mez
runs her][r][ fingahs ova the text, removing the lilts n weights,
ab.solvent....
Deena
says, "How do you see the
Diner and Dinner
Party influencing
future anthologies?"
lugh
says, "Yes - some work would appeal more to the angry, some
more to the gentle. The angry-gentle were left hanging, though,
and then there are the... you get the idea. Not a Q, BTW; just
mentioning what affects our work, IMHO."
Scott
says, "Sure. On the reflection of the gender. Though the
work involved women contributors, the unknown took on some qualities
of 'typical' locker room or school-yard behavior. Parts of it
were a consciously boys playing dirty type of thing. I don't
think that this was a negative thing necessarily, but its something
we noticed. As did Cynthia Riz, who wrote feminist critique
part of the unknown "
Margie
says, "Actually, I think that the ELO
directory is the natural place for this work to be continued.
Nothing like that existed when we started, for men. Although
there was Carolyn Guertin's Assemblage
for women"
jenniferley
says, "I think the framing Margie created for both of these
works is distinctive."
Marvella
says, "I'm honored to be the only mermaid in the men's anthology."
Jan
makes an announcement: If anyone who is currently using Lingua
as a guest would like a full user account here, please click
the REQUEST button in the Xpress tool bar and fill in the form.
You can also request a character by sending me an email at jan@mac.com.
Please provide the user name you want, your email address and
your full name. Thank you.
Deena
says, "Jan is the MOO meister and our MOO host. Three cheers
for Jan."
Jan
smiles.
Scott
shares a URL...<http://www.unknownhypertext.com/femcritique.htm>.
jenniferley
says, "Kate Hayles called the structure of Dinner
Party an
'open work'"
Tom
says, "What is an open work?"
mez
carves a sexless frame from jen's air, a sculpture of both faces,
act.u.all....
Andrea
and Guy quietly enter.
Deena
says, "Hi Andrea and guy, we are talking about the role of the
Diner and Dinner
Party
in future anthologizing."
lugh
says, "Gods and Thunders, this is a beast over a text connection.
I want split screen!!!"
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Margie: what's curious is that, in later indices that
are truly hypertextual, readers would be able to filter/sort
entries by gender, year published, whatever--transparent, "Ideology-free"
indexing!"
lugh
says, "Open work? Like, inviting participation or some such?
Neat idea..."
jenniferley
says, "We just have to hope Netscape or IE doesn't decide
to rewrite how html functions yet again, right??"
mez
open sauc codes, open window vent][ings][, o][h!][.pens and
pencils...
Margie
says, "Yay, Bobby, and that is kind of what we have with ELO
directory --although not a gender category--everything else
Rob K. and Nick could get in....folks can find most anything,
now, and have fun"
jenniferley
says, "I think she meant open as far as construction, but I
shouldn't speak for her .."
The
housekeeper arrives to remove Weishaus and Molde_Guest.
Deena
says, "This goes back to what Margie started us with--how are
people coping with the instability of the technology?"
lugh
says, "I heard that, especially w/Netscape dumbing down functionality
for 6.0 to be *more* like IE. Narf!"
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Janet asks--do you design for a particular browser then,
lugh?"
JimR
says, "That's why I like things that play in Java space, where
you don't depend on the browser [sic] for anything but a blank
space."
mez
leans down 2 the room's florr, a velvet sounding boarded surface,
and listens....
Deena
says, "BTW, we are doing the Online
Writers workshop on the last Saturday of the month.. Next
Sat is Joel Weishaus' work, Inside
the Skull House and Feb will be Marjorie's work."
Margie
says, "I think that open work referred to the fact that so many
different forms of art/lit were flowing in, and there were so
many different kinds of writing."
Scott
says, "We're also going to add more filtering capacity
to the ELO
directory --although not a gender category--everything else
Rob K. and Nick could get in....folks can find most anything,
-- one thing we're hoping to get in this year is reader reviews,
and eventually collaborative filtering."
Tom
says, "I hit overload again Deena - these MOOS do me in. Goodbye,
all"
The
housekeeper arrives to remove Bobbyrabyd and Tom.
Deena
says, "Thanks for coming!"
lugh
says, "That's not as portable as one might wish, though. Too
many doodads can be problematical..."
weishaus
arrives. jenniferley says, "Welcome back Joel :)"
Deena
says, "Hi welcome back Joel. Can you give the URL for your work
for next week's writing workshop?"
weishaus
says, "My connect failed. AOL! What a drag!"
Cybele
says, "Jim are you saying that java is browser independent?"
Deena
says, "There are so many issues as well that we have not covered"
Scott
shares a URL...<http://directory.eliterature.org>.
Margie
says, "Thanks, Scott!!"
mez
D.texts a soft murmuring, voices swooning in2 b&w, a soft
echo of the page...
Cybele
says, "Javascript certainly isn't..."
Margie
says, "Joel, I am sorry we got off the topic of links--this
is a hot one"
Bobbyrabyd
reenters. Deena passes out horseless carriages to all and is
so happy that they only quit once every five minutes!
lugh
says, "Java functionality it tied somewhat to the browser, yes,
and the platform as well, McNealy notwithstanding."
Deena
is being sarcastic again, as her computer lies dying..
a.c.chapman
says, "Some of the work I've been doing (like the Impermanence
Agent) specifically exploits bugs/features in a particular
browser, that will, in all likelihood be evolved out of that
browser. So it'll be both dated and inaccessible very soon."
Deena
says, "Yes, my work of short stories, Samplers,
exploited a Storyspace
bug, which got fixed before we could publish Samplers. Doing
a retro-program took a lot of Eastgate's
efforts!"
Cybele
says, "That's a great idea a.c."
mez
snatches 1 voice, a crooner's tongue, and stitches it 2 a lilting
linked tone...
Margie
says, "a.c., the issue of the browsers is quite discouraging."
Deena
says, "We come back to archiving and inaccessibility once
again..." and riverruns around in circles.
jenniferley
says, "Adam, do you think that is something authors just have
to accept right now ... that the work may be very temporal??"
Cybele
says, "Sure would be nice to populate the internet with
browser-free works."
Deena
says, "Yet mEIKAL is writing for readers 2 centuries from now.
How do you reconcile that?"
mez
kant hear, can't speak, kant d-tect a pulse, connection dead,
computer corpses...
Cybele
says, "Its just 1s & 0s. Ones & zeros / binary
code.... I think it's pretty sustainable..."
The
housekeeper arrives to remove JimR and clarissa.
a.c.chapman
says, "Well, I just think it's a different way of looking
at things. Most print writers don't really think they'll be
read in 80-200 years. I mean, realistically."
Margie
says, "One of the things that is difficult about Diner is that
some of the pieces ALREADY don't work on Net6--even Waterwater"
jenniferley
says, "Well depending on their egos ;)"
mez
molds a ivory stamp with the letters "Print Writers" backwards.
Deena
magically copies the stamp for all of us
lugh
says, "How would we do that? Browserless work for the PAC masses,
I mean?"
Cybele
says, "PAC?"
lugh
says, "Point and Click - those who forget that there's a keyboard,
too."
Andrea
tiptoes out.
jenniferley
thinks of the Amiga in her attic.
Deena
says, "Margie, was browser capability a factor in deciding which
works to show?"
Jan
[to jenniferley]: I think as long as you adhere to the W3C standards,
i.e. HTML or XML and avoid things like Flash etc your texts
will stand a long time...thought pure ASCII is probably the
safest if you want a text that lasts for a hundred years :)
Cybele
says, "Set up something like napster... for hypertext."
mez
washes her browserless face, her n.oh.sent code...
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Janet says, it seems that if you're working on a long-life
model (one that will work w/o tech), you're back to pens &
paper, no?"
Margie
says, "I wondered at first if I should try to keep the pieces
current, and then couldn't figure out how do upgrade even my
own!"
Deena
says, "I wanted to ask how people set up their works--the approaches
to long and short term survival seem very different."
JimR
returns and armele arrives. JimR says, "Sorry folks, the
olde Netscape croak got me ..."
Deena
says, "Hi Armele, we are talking about archiving and working
with hypertext works as the technology changes quickly."
jenniferley
says, "Jan, but so much of the experimental work is more than
text."
jenniferley
says, "That would rule out so much of the work many of
us like ... ack !!"
Scott
says, "Jan has a point there. there."
lugh
says, "Here! Here! ASCII forever!"
jenniferley
says, "That should make mez happy. "
a.c.chapman
says, "Back to structure as a part of the work."
Scott
says, "S kind of a choice between durable and technically
experimental everybody has to make."
Deena
says, "Jim, can you share a URL on your work?"
JimR
says, "Deena, you asked for a URL, here's one <http://www.well.com/user/jer/inter_works.html#Barrier_frames>
Bobbyrabyd
says, ""This piece, which I remember from TP21CL in '98,
is visual ecstasy!" to JimR"
JimR
says, "Thanks!"
Jan
[to jeniferey]: yes, but experimentation is always on the cutting
edge and so you have no guarantee that the technologies you
use will survive.
mez
offers jen a golden text][ract][ smile
weishaus
says, "I'm counting on a university library to copy and upgrade
my archive.""
Deena
hands out lifetime guarantees that libraries will archive materials,
along with certificates of ownership to the Brooklyn Bridge.
Scott
says, "There may also be a move to browserless, self-contained
aps."
mez
sup][app][licates, again...
Margie
says, "I wonder how the men in the
Diner feel who can no longer guarantee that these works
can be seen at all?"
a.c.chapman
says, "I guess the question I tend to ask myself is 'does this
piece need to be a computer piece, and if so why and how?' this
tends to lead to structural questions and experimentation."
mez
rep.lee.kates, 2wards...
lugh
says, "It's all input and light; well, maybe sound. The technology
is pretty simple. If we avoid proprietary products and hand
code, anything at all is possible inside *any* browser released
within the last three years."
Deena
says, "How do people feel about the value of "dead" inaccessible
works? Are they worth resurrecting? What is our history worth?"
Bobbyrabyd
sobs, hiccups at his mortality.
mez
weaves a small silken book out of the dead, the in.ack.cess][pit][able...
lugh
says, "I have a PDP-11 - what's dead or inaccessible?" I'm counting
on my DLT drive."
Scott
says, "That gets a lot more realistic as a widespread distrib.
mechanism if peer-to-peer really takes off."
Deena
says, "Scott, what is peer-to-peer?"
Scott
says, "Peer-to-peer is the tech behind napster -- its basically
a lot of people sharing materials directly from their hard drives
with other people on a network."
Cybele
says, "How hard is that to set up, Scott?"
Margie
says, "Yes, Scott, but there needs to be a platform, right"
lugh
says, "Peer to peer is nothing new; ever hear of ftp? uucp (unix
to UNIX copy program)? Apple networking...?"
Cybele
says, "No, just a format."
Scott
says, "Well, setting up a peer-to-peer network -- probably
hard for any of us to do but the technology is available and
getting improved."
JimR
says, "I have to say I don't think peer-to-peer has anything
to do with this. Peer-to-peer only influences the details of
who is the client and who is the server. There's no impact as
far as *what* is shared. Tell me what I'm missing ..."
Deena
says, "Yes, how does the transmission affect the idea that the
software may be inaccessible."
Margie
says, "Jim R. though, has been continually working to keep his
work going on new platforms!"
Cybele
says, "Noise"
Deena
says, "mEIKAL, what do you mean by noise? elaborate, please..."
Deena
says, "WHY do authors chose to use hypertext, new media, technology.
What are we saying that can't be said in good old reliable print?"
Scott
says, "I think its more how we're saying than what we're saying."
a.c.chapman
says, "Well, hopefully, both are important."
jenniferley
says, "Jan, I agree, but the situation for hypermedia is very
different from say, composing music, or creating paintings or
sculpture."
lugh
says, "There are works which read differently depending on ones
spur of the moment choices, which may never be thoroughly read.
You can't do that with a notebook. Can't."
Deena
says, "Jan and Jen, how is hypermedia different from other art
forms?"
mez
notes and sings the re-write, the book of Others, the actual
work...
mez
peers, a keyholian point, a collab.ore.ative sopace with a view...
Jan
says, "Well, I don't think it is all that different, on
a general level."
jenniferley
can see this could be a long discussion ... would love to have
it Jan face to face :)
Bobbyrabyd
says, "I'm betting the Electronic Literature Org's prize this
year is going to turn up some cool-app developments by the 15
February deadline."
Deena
says, "The trAce/ELO chat next February
4, 2001 will talk with Talan Memmott, winner of the New
Media Prize, then FraMe authors on
February 18, 2001,
and then the winner of the ELO prize in May
13, 2001."
Scott
says, "The key would indeed be the format."
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Isn't the point that there's no shared format?"
Jan
says, "Since it's about artistic expression through technology,
I mean painters also use technology, a hammer and chisel are
also technologies."
jenniferley
says, "What strikes me is how, for instance, we don't see
the pyramids as they were constructed. but we can SEE them."
lugh
says, "Nothing. You are missing nothing. The network topology
is not relevant to what for the art takes unless the art is
a network diagram."
lugh
says, "Form, rather."
Cybele
says, "We could all deliver content in a form that is not
platform dependent."
mez
transmissed the point, the P O V...
jenniferley
says, "With the netscape rewrite killing DHTML .. the work
vanishes."
mez
visions the e][mailed][vent horison, the New vanishing point][allistic
urge][
JimR
says, "Peer-to-peer has nothing to do with file formats. Any
format you could use with peer-to-peer you could use with http
or ftp or kermit."
jenniferley
says, "How do the men in the
Diner feel about this??"
Deena
says, "I still want to know why authors are choosing the forms
they choose--why are we using the technology, the graphics?
what are we able to say we couldn't say in any other way?"
Jan
says, "From what I understand, XML, rather than DHTML is
the W3C recommendation for the future."
Guy
says, "The big idea behind peer to peer is people to people.
Decentralize the content to the infrastructure."
Bobbyrabyd
shares a URL for the Technology Platforms for 21st Century Literature
Conference...<http://www.stg.brown.edu/conferences/TP21CL/>.
mez
plots a red graphian curve.
JimR
says, "Jen, I guess I saw that stuff as an oncoming freight
train and never wanted anywhere near DHTML."
Guy
says, "Oops not."
armele
says, "Isn't the concept about what you do, rather than
how you do it?"
a.c.chapman
says, "I think it is different, in that it's a New kind of temporal
work., a New kind of interaction with the audience -- not in
a choose your own adventure or rearrange this poem (OuLiPO)
sort of way."
jenniferley
says, "Yes, you did call that one Jim ... I remember in
SUNY :)"
Deena
says, "Right, and the next Brown conference will be Digital
Arts and Culture in April 2001."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Just a reminder: some of the people here chatted about
platform (in person) at a Brown conference (TP21CL)
two years ago . . . bookmark the proceedings for later review!"
mez
concepts, transcepts, seepage septums...
Deena
says, "So we can get temporality in here, and spatiality, and
maybe show structures in unique ways..."
Deena
says, "The reason I use the New media is to show the innate
structure of the work, to explore connections that can't be
made on paper."
armele
says, "Making text dynamic, rather than static?"
Deena
says, "Merging graphics with text."
Margie
says, "I think, D.,that many of us use the New coding, like
DHTML because the fun of it is saying something in a New way--maybe
not a New thing to say, but a way to say it that changes everything.
I saw this in the
Diner pieces"
Deena
says, "How do the men here merge graphics and images with the
text? How do the images affect that meaning?"
a.c.chapman
says, "Such quiet fellows."
mez
spies a bunch of fragmented wooden words in a dusty corner.
she crawled ova 2 them her knees skittering ova jags of techne
text and codeic crusts...
Scott
says, "Right -- wasn't trying to oversimplify, Jim. My
overall interest in peer to peer has more to with idea of how
people could build a content network that has some mechanism
for rewarding artists for the work, and that pulls things to
a well-searchable collaborative sub-network. But I can't explain
what I'm trying to talk about in a chat window. "
Margie
says, "Sometimes the graphics carried most of the content."
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Deena: males merge text and graphics nowhere near as
coolly as Christy."
Margie
says, "Well, Christy is a wonder, but the work in the
Diner is sumptuous."
Deena
passes out lots of wooden fragments and illuminates them in
cyberlight.
jenniferley
says, "DHTML allows different synaptic connections between parts
of a whole ... or it did for me."
jenniferley
says, "So I'll be sad to see it go ... have to learn a
New bag of tricks"
a.c.chapman
nods to jennifer
JimR
says, "Oh sure, if you're talking about the relationship to
audience, remuneration, etc., peer to peer is important there.
But I don't see if affecting what gets written."
Deena
says, "We can also take these conversations to the ELO bulletin
board for more thought out answers... I will post the questions
there at http://www.eliterature.org/cgi-bin/dcforum/dcboard.cgi?conf=DCConfID1"
Cybele
says, "So, Jim how do we transform browser & system
incompatibilities?"
mez
says, "Scott I think yr getting at the crux of the matter here.
with an urge 2 both create a network that supports and references,
great stuff"
Deena
says, "Jennifer, you may be able to substitute the connection
system for some of that DHTML connections"
lugh
says, "Look at your Kanjis,
Deena- it's just different to paper. Some things are a waste
of technology, or rather the medium is not relevant to the content,
but interactive text requires an interactive medium. There,
Deena - your work is not a waste of magnetic zones, Deena."
Deena says, "Thanks, Russ. " lugh says, "Narf."
Deena
says, "I was very impressed --blown away--with the graphics
in these works. There was some incredible works there..."
JimR
says, "Java has all the muscle one needs, but has too high a
load on non-programmers to "Use native". The trick is front
ends that generate the Java. I've been using one, called Jamba
-- just found out about another one yesterday called CrossArtist
-- it's free!"
mez
looks 2 a red blooded Sun ][system][, javaesqued and light in
scope and ochre tones...
Cybele
says, "Anything that works on a mac Jim?"
Deena
says, "Please give us the URL for CrossArtist, Jim"
JimR
says, "http://www.crossartist.comI
think ..."
a.c.chapman
says, "Jamba--that's
interesting, do you like it?"
Scott
says, "Also, I think the browser-independent stuff gets
more realistic the more people get broadband. One of the cool
things about .tk3 -- although it has a lot limitations and is
a proprietary format -- things created for it won't be drastically
altered every time Netscape decides to tweak its browser."
Deena
passes out sun systems and lots of aspirin for us nonprogrammers.
Cybele
says, "Not to mention that Java is really sluggish on my
machine & crashed it often."
armele
says, "Can you tell me about .tk3?"
jenniferley
says, "I'm curious ... we decided to make the
Diner English-language specific ... so who did we leave
out because of that?"
Deena
passes out superfast more than state of the art computers to
all writers and readers
JimR
says, "I like Jamba a lot. Interleaf bought it, strangled it,
now it's been sold again, and I don't know if the New owners
will make a go of it or not."
lugh
says, "JimR? I'm a developer and I see Java break way too often
to trust it on any machine over which I do not exercise control,
such as the machine of another viewing my work over the 'net."
mez
filtahs her broadband, playin a narrow tune...
Bobbyrabyd
says, "Nonsequitor: please raise your hand if you're coming
to DAC at Brown in April"
a.c.chapman
raises hand.
Stephanie/Janet
says, "I hope to be there, Bobby"
Deena
raises hand and adds "We are doing a two day writers workshop
(Ala CyberMountain) at the Digital
Arts and Culture conference in April in Brown University,
RI. See the Electronic
Writers Workshops schedules."
Margie
says, "The other thing to put on your calendar is the ELO
Symposium in September!"
a.c.chapman
smells pits.
Deena
says, "Please email me at chathost@eliterature.org
for info"
mez
plants her hands in a jumble of the virtual
lugh
says, "Probably a lot of people. Basque rhymes don't work in
English, f'rinstance."
weishaus
says, "Sorry, I had to go away and get something to eat. I was
starving in the
Diner!""
jenniferley
says, "And the E
Poetry 2001 Festival at SUNY Buffalo"
Bobbyrabyd
says, "ELO symposium at New School in NYC . . .""
jenniferley
says, "So many conferences, so little time :("
Jan
says, "I think that in electronic media, authors must come to
the understanding that a work (text or otherwise) cannot just
be published once and then live forever, works need to be maintained
and updated for New media types and formats much like software
programs."
mez
confers, her body light and silicon bright...
Scott
says, ". . . . begin momentary plug --- REMEMBER THE ELO AWARDS
--- ten grand in both fiction and poetry -- 25 days left --
BIG SHOW IN NEW YORK MAY 18th -- meet the media, get famous.
And such. ENTER TODAY."
Scott
shares a URL...<http://www.eliterature.org/Awards2001>.
Scott
says, "-- end plug"
Margie
says, "Jan, you are surely right. It is a cottage industry just
keeping one's home page up to snuff, tho!"
mez
says, "Hmmm"
jenniferley
says, "I think you're right Jan ... and realizing that is an
issue is a mind shift for writers of text, or painters or anyone
who expected their work to endure"
mez
says, "Love the snuff word:)"
armele
says, "So we come back to archiving work..."
Deena
says, "And snuffing work."
lugh
says, "As differentiated from hardware programs?"
mez
says, "Lol"
Deena
passes around little ivory snuffboxes that actually work.
armele
snuffs.
Margie
says, "What does up to snuff mean, mez/ do you think? good
enuff to sniff?"
lugh
says, "That depends. I make kinetic sculptures. They last, and
do not require updating."
mez
gently passes her rewurked ire, her ivory, her ink n papered
snuff in2.
Deena
says, "The aural/visual/ aspects of the works have blended so
much, we should probably add in scent as well."
jenniferley
says, "Archiving is certainly a major issue with New media
work, and it's not an easy one."
armele
says, "We'll be able to do that soon.."
Cybele
says, "How long til they rust?"
Stephanie/Janet
says, "Thanks to all--goodbye now!"
JimR
says, "The preservation issue is a large one -- much too large
for chat. One thing very interesting about Jamba is that it
generates a text file that is used as the program for its player.
This text file is quite readable and *SPECIFIES* the piece completely.
So the "Jamba text file" acts as a kind of preservation language."
Scott
says, "They got those smell printers now. I want to play
with one of them."
Margie
says, "Ha, Scott, be careful!"
jenniferley
says, "Watch out ... Scott is doing smells !!"
a.c.chapman
says, "Ewww. I don't want scents."
Deena
passes around scents and some nonscents too
Margie
says, "I would like a gardenia poem."
Deena
says, "Gardenias would be good. Roses would be good. I heard
about a company transferring scents through the web..."
Deena
says, "We are over time: any great thoughts we need to get in
here?"
armele
says, "Maybe each work needs a cut off point?"
mez
says, "Heh Margie, possibly..I love the connotations of
it, like a snuffing, a good ro][u][ot round in gritty places,
a hard look at aspects of work we usually ignore..."
lugh
says, "As systems become more powerful, they are frequently
used to emulate older/less capable systems. Our works will run
fine in emulators, y'know?"
JimR
says, "We've been so fixed on *presentations* that we haven't
investigated preservation languages. I think this is an important
subject."
armele
says, "Only that would negate the medium which it's made
in"
jenniferley
says, "Absolutely Jim"
Deena
says, "We have done some chats on preservation issues, but have
not reached conclusions. It seems to be like the Impermanence
Agent, building in obsolescence for temporary works or moaning
about keeping updated!"
JimR
says, "Emulators are OK as a "safety net", but somehow
blind reliance on emulators makes me nervous."
a.c.chapman
says, "I recently made a documentation version of The Agent,
and in a year or two, I think I'm going to be very happy I did."
lugh
says, "How so? It's light, sound and input. These are the media,
unless the desk is a part of the presentation ALA Electronic
Easel..."
Editor's note: Electronic Easel
was an exhibition at the University of Colorado, Boulder. We
lost the chat archive from Electronic Easel participants on
June 28, 2000, but have some
pictures...and assurances that a good time was held by all.
armele
says, "Being able to send something out so that it would
evolve without my constant intervention, would be a dream"
Margie
says, "Jim, you are so right about preservation--but we need
institutions to help with this, me saving my old Win3 won't
hack it"
Deena
says, "Jim, blind reliance on electricity is making me nervous!"
jenniferley
says, "Aha a smart hyper'text' ... updates itself as needed"
mez
pre.serves. presevers...
JimR
says, "How about preserving some of the important research hypertext
systems that none of us have had our hands on even for 5 minutes???"
Deena
says, "Yes, even my collection of old macs isn't really enough
"
jenniferley
says, "Time for me to run too ... it has been such a pleasure
to type with you all."
armele
says, "Evolves rather than updates."
lugh
says, "I mean a '386 emulator once all computers are made from
protein or some such. The same browser software, et cetera."
weishaus
says, "Even with print there are problems with translations,
even editions of books. There are always typos, and the text
over editions can change.""
jenniferley
says, "Many thanks to Deena for hosting"
mez
says, "Cya jen:)"
Guy
says, "Good night"
armele
says, "I second the thanks"
Margie
says, "I am off before I get caught by the rolling blackouts.
Deena, thanks so much for hosting this discussion of Diner--and
more--"
Deena
says, "Thanks for coming all of you writers, readers, collators,
and thinkers"
mez
thirds it
Cybele
says, "I gotta go too, thanks all for so New ideas..."
jenniferley
says, "And all those amazing guys and their work, and Margie,
and Steph .... and ..... Jan for the MOO .......night all"
weishaus
says, "Yes, thanks.""
lugh
says, "Thanks and you are welcome to all!"
A
puff of white smoke engulfs Jan as he vanishes into thin air
Deena
hands round thanks to all for their hard work. This will be
archived at http://www.eliterature.org/com/index.shtml.
mez
watches the nodes remote, disconnected, whispering in2 a n m.T.ing
ether...
The
housekeeper arrives to remove most guests.
Deena
says, "Who is left? WeE can keep going, but we could keep going
forever on these topics..."
lugh
says, "I'm here"
armele
says, "Me too"
lugh
says, "I'll stay if others do"
a.c.chapman
says, "Aloha"
Deena
says, "a.c. are you in Hawaii?"
mez
b-comes hazy, silken and webbish.............mez says, "Poof!"
and disconnects.
a.c.chapman
says, "No, just from there."
JimR
says, "I'm still here but it looks like things are winding down"
Deena
says, "Yes, Jim, thanks for coming and sharing your insights.
It is really hard to do this in a chat, but I like airing the
issues a bit :)"
armele
says, "Okay...hey Deena, I'm in the standalone MOOTcam,
how do I quit?"
Deena
says, "Type @quit"
lugh
says, "Thanks Jim - pleasure tweaking you and my brain both."
armele
says, "Okay, cool, I'll be here next week...had a great
time."
JimR
says, "A pleasure folks, I think I'll bail ..."
Deena
says, "See you in the trAce webboard next week."
lugh
says, "Cheers"
Deena
says, "Cheers. thanks Jim"
Deena
says, "a.c. Tell Noah Hi and congrats on the Impermanence
Agent and being in the Iowa
Review next month--sorry we forgot to mention it"
whatever
quietly enters.
Deena
says, "Hi whatever, we are winding down"
Deena
hands round glasses of winding down wine to all who are left
a.c.chapman
says, "Oh, thanks. yeah, we're pretty psyched about that."
lugh
says, "Whatever's a great handle."
Deena
is mad at herself for not thinking to promote it again..
The
housekeeper arrives to remove whatever.
lugh
says, "Motors whine when they wind down..."
a.c.chapman
says, "You shouldn't be mad. That's our job not yours."
Deena
says, "Right. Next time come up and promote it :)"
The
housekeeper arrives to cart disconnected guests off to bed.
lugh
says, "Crazy, yes; mad, no."
a.c.chapman
says, ";)"
Deena
says, "I should get out of here, though, folks. Kinkos costs..."
Deena
says, "It was great to see you guys, and I hope to see you again
at these chats..."
a.c.chapman
says, "Cool. Well, I guess I'll get back to work too. Must
finish before Simpson's. Thank you again."
lugh
says, "Cheers, all - I'm off to work."
--
End log: Monday, January 22, 2001 9:33:37 am CST
|